I In contrast Popeyes and McDonald’s Breakfast — Here is the Winner

I In contrast Popeyes and McDonald’s Breakfast — Here is the Winner

Jeffrey Greenberg/Common Pictures Group by way of Getty Pictures and Matt Cardy/Getty Pictures

  • Popeyes not too long ago launched a breakfast menu that is unique to the UK.
  • The corporate is aiming to deliver the UK a “New Orleans shake-up” with its Cajun-infused meals.
  • I in contrast the brand new menu with a number of of McDonald’s basic breakfast choices.

McDonald’s has lengthy dominated the fast-food breakfast market, however rivals equivalent to Taco Bell and Wendy’s are more and more trying to problem the multinational with new and novel choices.

McDonald’s started its foray into the breakfast market within the Nineteen Seventies, with its iconic Egg McMuffin breaking onto the scene in the midst of the last decade, following profitable assessments.

By 1977, the corporate had launched a full, nationwide breakfast menu, full with sausages, hash browns, and scrambled eggs, amongst different objects.

The breakfast menu rapidly grew to become a core a part of the corporate’s income stream, and it makes up round 25% of its US gross sales every year.

One fast-food chain that is aiming to problem McDonald’s dominance is Popeyes.

The New Orleans-based agency, which makes a speciality of fried rooster, launched a breakfast menu within the UK in September. It options some basic candy and savory choices, however prospects may ramp up their meals with Popeyes’ signature Cajun seasoning.

The corporate’s chief working officer, Neil Williamson, mentioned in a press launch: “Breakfast over right here was overdue a New Orleans shake-up and we’re happy Brits can now get their daring Cajun seasoning repair very first thing within the morning.”

I made a decision to place Popeyes’ new menu to the take a look at towards a few of McDonald’s basic objects.

I began with Popeyes’ Huge Cajun Roll

Nathan Rennolds/Enterprise Insider

The Huge Cajun Roll is among the core objects on Popeyes’ breakfast menu — and it isn’t for the faint-hearted. The comfortable brioche bun comes filled with a sausage patty, Cajun hash brown, egg, bacon, and cheese, with a wholesome dollop of Cajun ketchup to complete issues off.

The roll actually packs a punch and it was a filling begin to the day. However for me, the Cajun seasoning was maybe a bit a lot for breakfast, though some individuals might get a kick from the early hit of spice.

I might nonetheless go for the Mighty McMuffin if I had been going for a giant, stodgy takeaway to get the day began. Granted, the McDonald’s muffin is fairly easy — however that is what I am in search of from a breakfast. I believe Popeyes’ Cajun ketchup and the Cajun hash brown, whereas pleasant in their very own proper, had been a bit overkill earlier than 11 a.m.

I admit that my UK upbringing might make me barely biased right here, because the McDonald’s muffin is analogous — aside from the addition of cheese — to one thing my household would whip up on a Saturday morning.

McDonald’s Mighty McMuffin
Nathan Rennolds/Enterprise Insider

Subsequent, I attempted Popeyes’ Huge Breakfast Roll

Nathan Rennolds/Enterprise Insider

The Huge Breakfast Roll is Popeyes’ extra apparent reply to the Mighty McMuffin, crammed with a sausage patty, egg, bacon, and cheese in a brioche bun.

By way of style, it was actually a worthy contender for the McMuffin, however the brioche bun did not fairly do it for me. The additional chew from the muffin provided depth to the textures and a extra “breakfasty” really feel, whereas the brioche bun meant the Huge Breakfast Roll felt extra like a Huge Afternoon Burger.

Popeyes introduced it again with their extra conventional choices

Nathan Rennolds/Enterprise Insider

Popeyes’ Double Sausage, Egg, and Cheese muffin and the Double Bacon, Egg, and Cheese muffin had been each winners, as they had been precisely what I search for in a takeaway breakfast — hearty and filling, one thing McDonald’s additionally nailed with its Bacon and Egg McMuffin.

Nathan Rennolds/Enterprise Insider

McDonald’s additionally hit the mark with its hash brown. Popeyes provides its personal common hash brown and likewise a Cajun-seasoned different. Once more, the Cajun choice was a tasty, novel twist by itself, however I will be sticking to the common one throughout breakfast.

McDonald’s breakfast
Nathan Rennolds/Enterprise Insider

I additionally tried a number of of the marginally much less conventional objects from every chain’s menu, together with McDonald’s Tacky Bacon Flatbread and Popeyes’ Cinnamon Sugar Biscuit. Personally, I would not get both once more, as each had been dry and the flatbread lacked filling.

Popeyes suggests dressing the cinnamon biscuit with a layer of Nutella, which does enhance issues. However once more, I would not go and purchase this myself.

Nathan Rennolds/Enterprise Insider

I additionally sampled Popeyes’ Chocolate Mocha Milkshake to see the way it stacked up towards McDonald’s well-known, however generally scarce, milkshake vary.

The mocha twist was a pleasant changeup, though I am unsure I might be diving right into a shake on the best way to work.

Nathan Rennolds/Enterprise Insider

Simplicity wins

My largest takeaway from tasting the 2 menus is that, for me, simplicity wins, and McDonald’s benefit available in the market should mirror its realization of that.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply