I Tried 6 Frozen Turkey Burgers & These Have been the Absolute Greatest!
The product suggestions on this publish are suggestions by the author and/or skilled(s)
interviewed and don’t comprise affiliate hyperlinks. That means: If you happen to use these hyperlinks to purchase
one thing, we is not going to earn a fee.
Turkey is a lot extra than simply the centerpiece of your Thanksgiving desk or the filling in your membership sandwich. Whether or not it is floor up, sliced, roasted, become tacos, stirred into chili, or stuffed into bell peppers, there are a myriad of tasty and artistic methods to get pleasure from that versatile poultry. However one particularly in style and prevalent method to make use of turkey these days is subbing it for the meat in a traditional burger.
Apart from all of the dietitian-approved well being advantages of the proteinturkey burgers even have the potential to be actually tasty after they’re executed proper. And fortuitously for residence cooks who do not feel like forming their very own patties, there are a number of in style frozen turkey burger manufacturers gracing grocery retailer freezer aisles throughout the nation these days.
However which of these manufacturers is the very best you can purchase in 2023? I just lately got down to reply that query by attempting the entire manufacturers I might discover throughout journeys to a number of totally different grocery shops in my space: Butterball, Jenni-O, Applegate Organics, Bubba Burger, Dealer Joe’s, and Good & Collect (a non-public label Goal model).
Whereas I’d have liked to check out all of those manufacturers on an precise barbecue, my cozy New Jersey condo lacks a yard the place I might match a grill, sadly. So I ready every burger in a stovetop skillet per the package deal instructions, leaving the patties utterly plain so I might present essentially the most correct overview of their taste. A few of these turkey burgers had been so tasty that I had hassle choosing a winner, however one finally stood out to me as having the largest oomph by way of each taste and texture.
Learn on for my ideas on every turkey burger, beginning with my least favourite and ending with essentially the most mouthwatering model accessible to customers in 2023!
Applegate Organics Turkey Burgers
Per serving (1 patty): 150 cal, 8 g fats (1.5 g saturated fats), 105 mg sodium, 0 g carbs, 20 g protein
Applegate Organics’ Turkey Burgers are produced from turkeys which can be humanely raised with no antibiotics. A one-pound pack of 4 burgers price me $9.99.
The look: A bit on the smaller aspect and barely misshapen. Nonetheless, the skin of the patty developed a extremely engaging golden brown sear in the course of the cooking course of.
The style: Not dangerous, however fairly boring. The patty itself had a decently pleasurable, clear turkey taste, however the entire thing was woefully underseasoned and just a little dry. If I ever prepare dinner one in every of these burgers once more, I am going to give them a reasonably beneficiant dose of salt and pepper and high them with loads of veggies, cheese, and sauces earlier than digging in.
Along with being the least flavorful turkey burger I attempted on this style take a look at, I additionally thought that Applegate Organics was the worst deal. For context, eight Bubba Burger turkey burgers price me $8.99, whereas 4 Applegate Organics price me $9.99. Whereas some individuals would possibly suppose it is value it to pay extra for a product simply because it is natural, I desire the concept of getting extra non-organic meals for a cheaper price.
Dealer Joe’s Turkey Burgers
Per serving (1 patty): 180 cal, 10 g fats (2.5 g saturated fats), 280 mg sodium, 0 g carbs, 22 g protein
Dealer Joe’s Turkey Burgers are made with a mix of white and darkish turkey meat, which is seasoned with kosher salt and rosemary extract. A one-pound pack of 4 patties price me $3.79.
The look: These had been about the identical dimension and thickness because the Applegate Organics burgers, however just a little rounder in form. Whereas they developed a little bit of a sear in the course of the cooking course of, the colour wasn’t fairly as pronounced as a few of the different patties I attempted.
The style: This patty additionally boasted a extremely clear and contemporary turkey taste. Nonetheless, regardless that it was barely higher seasoned than the Applegate Organics model, the flavour did not pack as a lot as punch as a few of the greater rating manufacturers I attempted. I’ve little question that Dealer Joe’s prospects could make a extremely tasty meal out of those patties by seasoning and topping them as they please, however I ranked them on the decrease finish of the spectrum just because different manufacturers had been tremendous flavorful as is.
Bubba Burger Turkey Burgers
Per serving (1 patty): 190 cal, 11 g fats (2.5 g saturated fats), 280 mg sodium, 0 g carbs, 22 g protein
Bubba Burger’s Turkey Burgers comprise no synthetic substances, components, or preservatives. A 32-ounce pack of eight burgers price me $8.99.
The look: I’ve a reasonably good quantity of expertise with Bubba Burger, and I swear that each burger I’ve ever seen from this model has been oddly misshapen. The patty itself developed a great sear and it was fairly thick regardless of being just a little too small to suit the bun.
The style: My takeaway in regards to the taste of this patty is just about the identical as my takeaways for the Applegate and Dealer Joe’s patties. The style is completely high-quality, albeit a bit boring. I would have to improve it with my very own seasonings and toppings with the intention to actually get pleasure from it. What pushed Bubba Burger forward of the others, nonetheless, was the feel. As a result of the patty was thicker, it appeared to carry its juices significantly better in the course of the cooking course of that the Applegate Organics and Dealer Joe’s burgers.
Good & Collect Turkey Burgers
Per serving (1 patty): 190 cal, 9 g fats (2 g saturated fats), 450 mg sodium, 0 g carbs, 26 g protein
Good & Collect’s Turkey Burgers are produced from turkey raised with none antibiotics, added hormones, or steroids. A 32-ounce pack of six burgers price me $9.59.
The look: Huge, thick, and the right dimension for the bun. Nonetheless, the patty was on the paler aspect and did not develop fairly pretty much as good of a sear as a few of the different manufacturers.
The style: Far more flavorful than the underside three manufacturers on this style take a look at, which is sensible contemplating that black pepper, dehydrated garlic, onion powder, and salt are all talked about on the substances listing. Good & Collect additionally wins factors for the truth that the within of the thick patty did not dry out an excessive amount of in the course of the cooking course of.
My one critique is that the burger had a refined disagreeable style that kind of jogged my memory of chemical compounds, but it surely wasn’t so sturdy that it ruined the complete expertise for me. If this patty got here with all my favourite burger toppings, I in all probability would not have even seen it.
Jennie-O Seasoned Turkey Burgers
Per serving (1 patty): 230 cal, 14 g fats (4 g saturated fats), 620 mg sodium, 0 g carbs (1 g sugar), 25 g protein
Jennie-O’s Seasoned Turkey Burgers comprise no synthetic substances and had been produced from turkey raised with none added hormones or steroids. A 32-ounce pack of six burgers price me $9.99.
The look: So well-browned that I might have simply mistaken it for a beef burger. The superbly sized patty got here out of the pan extremely well-seared on each side.
The style: I actually had hassle discovering any flaws with this feature. The patty itself was huge, thick, and in no way dry, whereas the sear on the skin added a extremely pleasurable textural chew to the burger. The seasoning ranges had been additionally just about excellent. I loved this feature a lot that I had some critical hassle deciding whether or not to rank it in first or second place. However after loads of additional bites and far thought, Jennie-O’s wasn’t the model that caught out to me as having the largest oomph in each taste and texture.
Butterball Unique Seasoned Turkey Burgers
Per serving (1 patty): 260 cal, 15 g fats (4.5 g saturated fats), 500 mg sodium, 2 g carbs (1 g sugar), 28 g protein
Butterball’s Unique Seasoned Turkey Burgers comprise no added hormones or steroids. A 32-ounce field of six burgers price me $10.99.
The look: Just like the Jenni-O and Good & Collect turkey burgers, Butterball’s patty was the right dimension and thickness for my burger bun. It additionally developed a remarkably good crust across the outdoors in the course of the cooking course of.
The style: Fairly excellent, so far as frozen turkey burgers go. To begin with, Butterball’s patties had the very best taste out of all of the choices I attempted. It was tremendous savory, nicely seasoned, and general actually tasty. However what actually pushed it over the sting for me was the feel. That well-developed crust across the outdoors encased a superbly juicy and moist inside. I am positive that Butterball’s turkey burgers could be much more pleasurable loaded up with my favourite toppings, however I could not assist however take chew after chew even when these had been plain.